Episode 5.03: Emotional Immaturity in South Asian Parenting: The Origin Story (Part 1 of 2)

In this thought-provoking podcast episode, we delve into the complex world of emotional immaturity and its profound impact on South Asian families and their children. Drawing inspiration from Lindsay C. Gibson's book, "Adult Children of Emotionally Immature Parents," we explore the history, cultural context, and real-life stories that illuminate the struggles and triumphs of individuals raised by emotionally immature parents. We delve deep into the intricate world of South Asian parenting and uncover the roots of emotional immaturity within these families. Our leading question takes us on a journey through cultural norms, historical influences, and the impact on the wellness and socialization of South Asian children. Our exploration begins with a critical look at South Asian parenting through the lens of emotional availability and connection. We question the essence of "good parenting" and the extent to which emotional needs are acknowledged in this culture. We examine the significance of emotional intimacy in parent-child relationships and dissect what successful parenting looks like in South Asian households. The legacy of Partition in 1947 casts a long shadow on mental health and emotional expression in South Asia. We explore how the upheaval disrupted healthcare services, and the silence of mental health professionals had lasting consequences. We introduce the ancient Sanskrit text Natyasastra and its "rasa" theory, which forms the basis of the Indian approach to emotions. Shifting our focus to parental emotion socialization, we delve into strategies used by South Asian parents, ranging from problem-focused and emotion-focused reactions to non-supportive methods like punitive reactions, minimization reactions, and distress reactions. We contemplate the profound implications of these emotional dynamics, including the development of internalizers and externalizers in adult children.

Sources:

  1. Eisenberg N, Cumberland A, Spinrad TL. Parental Socialization of Emotion. Psychol Inq. 1998

  2. Kathuria, Kapadia, Friedlmeier, Emotion Socialization in the Indian Cultural Context. Online Readings in Psychology and Culture. March 2023

  3. Walker, Raval. Asian Indian Immigrant and White American Maternal Emotion Socialization and Child Socio-Emotional Functioning. Journal of Child and Family Studies. May 2015.

  4. Sharma. Legacies of Partition in Mental Health. Media Diversified. August 2018

  5. Weisskirch. Psychosocial Intimacy, Relationships with Parents, and Well-being among Emerging Adults. Journal of Child and Family Studies. June 2018

  6. Ibrahim. Review: The Psychological Impact of the Partition of India. Refugee History. January 2019

Tanushree